Your Local Independent Insurance Agency in Oklahoma
Get the Right Home, Auto, Renters, or Business Coverage Fast
From home and auto to renters and business policies, we help you find the coverage that fits your life, your budget, and your peace of mind.
Auto
Home
Life
Buisness
Watercraft
Rentor
Motorcycle
Travel
Mobile
Bonds
Trusted Insurance Partners
Insurance Solutions
We Provide Across Oklahoma
Homeowners insurance
Protect your home with a home owners insurance policy. Homeowners insurance is an affordable, flexible coverage which can be customized to suit your needs.
Auto insurance
Buying an auto insurance policy can be an overwhelming task. It’s important to find the right coverage that covers you for all your needs, but also won’t break the bank. Compare and find the perfect policy for you with us!
Renters insurance
Renters insurance is a policy that can help you protect against financial loss when property in your rental home or apartment is damaged or destroyed.
Umbrella insurance
You know the feeling of dread when you think about your home, belongings and happiness being threatened by a natural disaster; an umbrella policy can help protect you from the financial uncertainty.
Commercial Auto Insurance
If you are running a business, it is crucial that you have this in your plan. Stop worrying about theft and vandalism. Start driving on the road without the stress of paying for how your vehicle is handled in a driver’s insurance claim.
Commercial Property Insurance
Owning a commercial property is a huge responsibility. The Commercial Prop Insurance Program provides you with the peace of mind that your investment is protected and that you are operating within the scope of the law.
Workers Compensation
Workers’ compensation insurance provides protection against liability for injuries to employees that result from their work.
Special Event Insurance
This is the only event insurance policy that provides coverage both for your property and for your liability, in case disaster strikes. It covers you for events like hosting a sporting event, putting on a concert, or throwing a birthday party!
Cyber Liability Insurance
Protect against cyber attacks and data breaches
A Professional
& Hard Working Insurance Team
Bringing Your Coverage Together With Care
When you trust someone with your home, car, or business, you want to work with a team that puts your needs first. At Allegiant Insurance, that commitment to our clients and communities continues to be recognized across Oklahoma.
In 2025, Allegiant Insurance Agency was voted Best Insurance Agency in Stillwater, and our co-owner, Kyle Goodin, was named Best Insurance Agent.
Then in 2026, we were honored again, this time being voted #1 Insurance Agency and Kyle Goodin the #1 Insurance Agent of the Cimarron Valley. This recognition is especially meaningful because the voting pool stretched across 3 counties and 10 different towns throughout the Cimarron Valley, making it a true regional award from the communities we serve.
These awards reflect more than recognition; they represent how we do business. As an independent agency, we offer the strength of over 50 carriers combined with the personal service of a local team that genuinely cares about protecting what matters most to you.
With multiple locations across Oklahoma, we remain committed to delivering better coverage, better prices, and a better experience. We’re incredibly grateful to every client and community member who has trusted us, supported us, and taken the time to vote for Allegiant Insurance.
See What Our Customers Are Saying
Leave us a 
review
Leave us a 
review
Why Clients Rely on Allegiant Insurance
Local, Veteran-Owned, and Community-Focused
We live and work right here in Oklahoma, so we understand the risks, rates, and needs of Stillwater, Claremore, and the surrounding communities better than anyone.
Independent Agency With 50+ Carrier Options
We’re not tied to one company. We shop the entire marketplace for you, so you get the right coverage and the most competitive price without doing any of the work.
Award-Winning Service You Can Count On
We were voted Best Insurance Agency in Stillwater for 2025, and our co-owner, Kyle Goodin, was named Best Insurance Agent. That recognition reflects our commitment to honesty, transparency, and real customer care.
Simple, Stress-Free Insurance Experience
Insurance shouldn’t be confusing. We explain your options clearly, guide you through every step, and help you choose coverage that truly fits your life.
Fast Quotes & Reliable Claim Support
From quick quotes to hands-on support when you need it most, our team stays by your side, long after your policy is issued.
Protection for Every Stage of Life
Whether you’re a homeowner, driver, renter, or business owner, we provide affordable insurance solutions that grow with you.
Protect What Matters Most, With a Team That’s Truly Allegiant.
Get your free quote or speak with a local agent today.
